Incident: Tesla Recalls Vehicles Due to Boombox Software Issue

Published Date: 2022-02-10

Postmortem Analysis
Timeline 1. The software failure incident involving the recall of Tesla vehicles due to the "Boombox" feature obscuring pedestrian warning noises happened in December 2020 [124320]. 2. The article [124043] mentions that the Boombox feature was first released in 2020, indicating that the software failure incident occurred in 2020.
System 1. Boombox feature in Tesla vehicles, including 2020-2022 Model S, Model X, Model Y, and 2017-2022 Model 3 vehicles [Article 124320, Article 124043]
Responsible Organization 1. The software failure incident in the Tesla vehicles, specifically related to the "Boombox" feature obscuring the required Pedestrian Warning System sound, was caused by Tesla itself due to the implementation of the Boombox functionality that allowed sounds to be played through an external speaker while the vehicle is in motion, leading to non-compliance with federal motor vehicle safety standards [Article 124320]. 2. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) played a role in causing the software failure incident by increasing scrutiny on Tesla and issuing recalls, including the one related to the Boombox feature violating safety standards [Article 124043].
Impacted Organization 1. Pedestrians, cyclists, and the blind were impacted by the software failure incident as the required Pedestrian Warning System sound was obscured due to the "Boombox" feature in Tesla vehicles [124320]. 2. Tesla owners and drivers were impacted by the software failure incident as they had to have the Boombox feature disabled through an over-the-air software update [124320]. 3. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) was impacted by the software failure incident as they had to issue recalls and increase scrutiny on Tesla due to various software issues [124320, 124043].
Software Causes 1. The failure incident was caused by the "Boombox function" in Tesla vehicles, which allowed sounds to be played through an external speaker while the vehicle is in motion, obscuring the required Pedestrian Warning System sound [124320]. 2. The software issue was related to the violation of federal safety standards that require pedestrian warning noises from electric cars, as these vehicles make very little noise while traveling [124043]. 3. Tesla addressed the failure incident by performing an over-the-air software update that disabled the Boombox functionality when the vehicle is in Drive, Neutral, and Reverse modes [124320].
Non-software Causes 1. The failure incident was caused by the "Boombox" feature in Tesla vehicles allowing sounds to be played through an external speaker while the vehicle is in motion, which obscured the required Pedestrian Warning System sound, leading to a recall [124320, 124043]. 2. The failure incident was also caused by Tesla vehicles violating federal safety standards that require pedestrian warning noises from electric cars, as these vehicles make very little noise while traveling, due to the Boombox function [124043].
Impacts 1. The software failure incident involving the "Boombox" feature in Tesla vehicles led to a recall of 578,607 vehicles in the United States due to pedestrians potentially not hearing the required warning sound of an approaching car, which could pose a safety risk [Article 124320]. 2. The incident resulted in Tesla issuing an over-the-air software update to disable the Boombox functionality when the vehicle is in Drive, Neutral, and Reverse modes, affecting the user experience and functionality of the feature [Article 124320]. 3. The recall highlighted concerns about Tesla's software testing practices, with the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) increasing scrutiny over the company shipping vehicles with software that may not be properly tested before release, raising questions about the overall software quality assurance processes [Article 124043]. 4. The software failure incident added to Tesla's series of recalls, with this being one of several recalls in a short period, indicating potential challenges in maintaining software quality and addressing software-related issues promptly [Article 124043]. 5. The incident showcased the regulatory implications of software failures, as NHTSA raised concerns about Tesla's compliance with federal motor vehicle safety standards related to minimum sound requirements for electric vehicles, emphasizing the importance of adhering to safety regulations in software development for automotive systems [Article 124320].
Preventions 1. Proper testing of software before release: The software failure incident could have been prevented if Tesla had conducted thorough testing of the "Boombox" feature and its interaction with the Pedestrian Warning System to ensure compliance with federal safety standards [Article 124043]. 2. Compliance with safety regulations: Ensuring that the software features, such as the Boombox function, comply with federal safety standards and regulations regarding minimum sound requirements for electric vehicles could have prevented the incident [Article 124320]. 3. Implementation of robust software update procedures: Having a robust process for software updates, including ensuring that updates are thoroughly tested and validated before deployment, could have prevented the need for a recall to disable the Boombox functionality through an over-the-air software update [Article 124320].
Fixes 1. An over-the-air software update that will disable the Boombox functionality when the vehicle is in Drive, Neutral, and Reverse modes could fix the software failure incident related to the obscuring of pedestrian warning noises [124320]. 2. Disabling the Boombox feature using an over-the-air update was implemented to address the violation of federal safety standards requiring pedestrian warning noises from electric cars [124043].
References 1. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) [Article 124320, Article 124043] 2. Tesla Inc [Article 124320, Article 124043] 3. Elon Musk [Article 124043]

Software Taxonomy of Faults

Category Option Rationale
Recurring one_organization, multiple_organization (a) The software failure incident having happened again at one_organization: The article [124043] mentions that Tesla has faced multiple recalls over the last few months due to software issues. Specifically, the article highlights that Tesla had to recall nearly 579,000 vehicles due to a software issue related to the "Boombox" feature that obscured pedestrian warning noises. This incident is part of a series of recalls by Tesla to address software-related issues, indicating a recurring problem within the organization. (b) The software failure incident having happened again at multiple_organization: The article [124043] also mentions that Tesla is not the only company facing software-related issues. It states that Tesla is under scrutiny from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) over concerns that vehicles are being shipped with software that isn't properly tested before release. Additionally, the article highlights that other companies have faced similar issues, such as recalls related to windshield defrosting risks, seat belt chime issues, and self-driving mode issues. This suggests that software failures are not unique to Tesla but are also affecting other organizations in the automotive industry.
Phase (Design/Operation) design, operation (a) The software failure incident related to the design phase can be seen in the case of Tesla's "Boombox" feature. The feature allowed sounds to be played through an external speaker while the vehicle is in motion, which obscured the required Pedestrian Warning System sound, leading to a recall of 578,607 vehicles in the United States [124320, 124043]. This failure was due to a design flaw in the software that did not comply with federal motor vehicle safety standards on minimum sound requirements for electric vehicles. (b) The software failure incident related to the operation phase can be observed in the case of Tesla's vehicles equipped with the "Boombox" feature. The feature allowed drivers to blast sounds and music through external speakers while the vehicles were moving, violating federal safety standards that require pedestrian warning noises from electric cars. This misuse of the feature during vehicle operation led to the recall of nearly 579,000 vehicles [124043].
Boundary (Internal/External) within_system (a) The software failure incident related to the Tesla vehicles' "Boombox" feature can be categorized as within_system. The issue arose from the functionality of the Boombox feature itself, which allowed sounds to be played through external speakers while the vehicle was in motion, obscuring the required Pedestrian Warning System sound [124320]. Tesla addressed this issue by performing an over-the-air software update to disable the Boombox functionality when the vehicle is in Drive, Neutral, and Reverse modes [124320]. This indicates that the failure originated from within the system's software design and implementation.
Nature (Human/Non-human) non-human_actions, human_actions (a) The software failure incident occurring due to non-human actions: - The software failure incident in the articles is related to the "Boombox" feature in Tesla vehicles that allows sounds to be played through an external speaker while the vehicle is in motion, obscuring the required Pedestrian Warning System sound [Article 124320]. - The failure was due to the Boombox function violating federal safety standards that require pedestrian warning noises from electric cars, as these vehicles make very little noise while traveling [Article 124043]. (b) The software failure incident occurring due to human actions: - The article mentions that Tesla is under scrutiny from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) over concerns that vehicles are being shipped with software that isn't properly tested before release [Article 124043]. - Elon Musk, the founder of Tesla, responded to questions about the recall on Twitter, indicating that the decision to disable the Boombox feature was made due to external pressure, implying human involvement in the decision-making process [Article 124043].
Dimension (Hardware/Software) hardware, software (a) The software failure incident occurring due to hardware: - The article mentions that Tesla is recalling vehicles because the "Boombox function" allows sounds to be played through an external speaker while the vehicle is in motion, which may obscure the required Pedestrian Warning System sound. This issue is related to the hardware component of the vehicles, specifically the external speaker system [124320]. - The article also states that the NHTSA found that cars and SUVs with the Boombox function violated federal safety standards that require pedestrian warning noises from electric cars. This violation of safety standards is related to the hardware aspect of the vehicles [124043]. (b) The software failure incident occurring due to software: - The articles highlight that Tesla will perform an over-the-air software update to disable the Boombox functionality when the vehicle is in Drive, Neutral, and Reverse modes. This indicates that the software aspect of the vehicles is being addressed through a software update to resolve the issue [124320]. - Additionally, the article mentions that Tesla had to recall vehicles equipped with 'Full Self-Driving' software that allowed the vehicles to run through stop signs at low speeds without coming to a complete halt. This issue with the self-driving software is a software-related failure incident [124043].
Objective (Malicious/Non-malicious) non-malicious (a) The software failure incident related to the Tesla vehicles' "Boombox" feature can be categorized as non-malicious. The failure occurred due to the "Boombox function" allowing sounds to be played through an external speaker while the vehicle is in motion, which obscured the required Pedestrian Warning System sound, leading to a violation of federal safety standards [124320, 124043]. This issue was addressed by Tesla through an over-the-air software update to disable the Boombox functionality when the vehicle is in Drive, Neutral, and Reverse modes [124320].
Intent (Poor/Accidental Decisions) poor_decisions, accidental_decisions (a) The software failure incident related to the Tesla recall of 578,607 vehicles in the United States due to the "Boombox" feature obscuring the required Pedestrian Warning System sound can be categorized under poor_decisions. This is because the Boombox feature allowed sounds to be played through an external speaker while the vehicle is in motion, which ultimately led to the failure to comply with federal motor vehicle safety standards on minimum sound requirements for electric vehicles [124320]. (b) The software failure incident can also be categorized under accidental_decisions as it was mentioned that the feature was disabled using an over-the-air update after it was found to violate federal safety standards requiring pedestrian warning noises from electric cars. The feature was initially released in 2020 via a software update, enabling users to broadcast sound outside the car via built-in external speakers, but it was later deemed unsafe and disabled [124043].
Capability (Incompetence/Accidental) development_incompetence (a) The software failure incident related to development incompetence can be seen in the case of Tesla's recall of 578,607 vehicles in the United States due to the "Boombox" feature obscuring the required Pedestrian Warning System sound. This issue arose because the "Boombox function" allowed sounds to be played through an external speaker while the vehicle was in motion, which led to the failure to comply with federal motor vehicle safety standards on minimum sound requirements for electric vehicles [124320]. (b) The software failure incident related to accidental factors can be observed in the case of Tesla's recalls, including the recall of 27,000 vehicles due to a windshield defrosting risk, the recall of 817,000 vehicles due to an issue with the seat belt chime, and the recall of 54,000 vehicles for rolling through stop signs in self-driving mode. These incidents were addressed and fixed with software updates, indicating that the failures were not intentional but rather accidental issues that needed to be rectified [124043].
Duration temporary (a) The software failure incident related to the Tesla vehicles' "Boombox" feature can be considered as a temporary failure. The issue with the Boombox function obscuring the required Pedestrian Warning System sound was addressed through an over-the-air software update that disabled the feature when the vehicle is in Drive, Neutral, and Reverse modes [124320]. Additionally, the article mentions that the feature was disabled using an over-the-air update, indicating that the failure was temporary and could be resolved through a software update [124043].
Behaviour crash, omission, timing, value, other (a) crash: The software failure incident related to the Tesla vehicles' "Boombox" feature can be categorized as a crash. The issue with the Boombox function obscuring the required Pedestrian Warning System sound led to a recall of 578,607 vehicles in the United States [124320]. This failure resulted in the system losing its state and not performing its intended function of providing the necessary warning sounds to pedestrians. (b) omission: The software failure incident can also be categorized as an omission. The Boombox feature allowed sounds to be played through an external speaker while the vehicle was in motion, which obscured the required Pedestrian Warning System sound, omitting the performance of the intended function [124320]. (c) timing: The software failure incident can be categorized as a timing issue. The Boombox function allowed sounds to be played through external speakers at inappropriate times, such as while the vehicle was in motion, affecting the timing of the system's intended functions [124043]. (d) value: The software failure incident can be categorized as a value issue. The Boombox feature, which allowed drivers to play sounds and music through external speakers, violated federal safety standards that require pedestrian warning noises from electric cars, impacting the value of the system's intended functions [124043]. (e) byzantine: The software failure incident does not align with a byzantine behavior as described in the articles. (f) other: The software failure incident can be categorized as an "other" behavior due to the system behaving in a way not described in the options (a to e). The incident involved the system allowing the playing of sounds through external speakers, which was not in compliance with federal safety standards, leading to the recall of the vehicles [124043].

IoT System Layer

Layer Option Rationale
Perception sensor, processing_unit, embedded_software (a) sensor: The software failure incident related to the perception layer of the cyber physical system that failed was due to contributing factors introduced by sensor error. The failure was specifically related to the Pedestrian Warning System (PWS) speaker, which is a sensor used to emit warning sounds for pedestrians. The issue arose because the "Boombox function" in Tesla vehicles allowed sounds to be played through an external speaker, obscuring the required Pedestrian Warning System sound, thus impacting the sensor's functionality [124320, 124043]. (c) processing_unit: The failure was also related to contributing factors introduced by processing error. Tesla addressed the issue through an over-the-air software update that disabled the Boombox functionality when the vehicle was in Drive, Neutral, and Reverse modes. This indicates that the processing unit, responsible for executing the software commands, was involved in the failure incident [124320, 124043]. (e) embedded_software: Additionally, the failure was linked to contributing factors introduced by embedded software error. Many of Tesla's recent recalls, including the one related to the Boombox feature, were to address software issues. The Boombox feature itself was introduced in December 2020 through a software update, enabling users to customize sounds and play them through external speakers, indicating a role of embedded software in the failure incident [124320, 124043].
Communication unknown The software failure incident reported in the articles does not directly relate to the communication layer of the cyber physical system. The failure was primarily associated with the "Boombox" feature in Tesla vehicles, which allowed sounds to be played through external speakers, potentially obscuring the required Pedestrian Warning System sound. The failure was more about the functionality and compliance with federal safety standards rather than issues at the communication layer of the cyber physical system. Therefore, the failure was not at the link_level or connectivity_level.
Application TRUE The software failure incident related to the application layer of the cyber physical system that failed is evident in the articles. The failure in this case was due to a software feature called "Boombox" in Tesla vehicles that allowed sounds to be played through an external speaker while the vehicle was in motion, obscuring the required Pedestrian Warning System sound. This failure was attributed to the application layer as it involved a feature that was not compliant with federal motor vehicle safety standards and introduced risks related to pedestrian safety [Article 124320, Article 124043].

Other Details

Category Option Rationale
Consequence non-human, theoretical_consequence, other (a) death: There were no reports of deaths related to the software failure incident mentioned in the articles. (b) harm: The software failure incident did not result in physical harm to individuals. (c) basic: The software failure incident did not impact people's access to food or shelter. (d) property: The software failure incident did not result in any direct impact on people's material goods, money, or data. (e) delay: There is no specific mention of people having to postpone an activity directly due to the software failure incident. (f) non-human: The software failure incident impacted non-human entities, specifically in terms of violating federal safety standards related to pedestrian warning noises from electric cars. (g) no_consequence: The articles do not mention any real observed consequences of the software failure incident. (h) theoretical_consequence: There were potential consequences discussed, such as the violation of federal safety standards and the need for recalls to address software issues, but there were no specific incidents of these theoretical consequences occurring. (i) other: The software failure incident led to recalls of Tesla vehicles due to issues with the "Boombox" feature obscuring pedestrian warning noises, violating federal safety standards, and requiring over-the-air software updates to disable the problematic functionality.
Domain transportation (a) The failed system was intended to support the transportation industry. The software failure incident involved Tesla vehicles, specifically the "Boombox" feature, which allowed sounds to be played through an external speaker while the vehicle is in motion. This feature obscured the required Pedestrian Warning System sound, which is crucial for pedestrian safety in electric vehicles [Article 124320, Article 124043]. (b) The transportation industry was directly impacted by the software failure incident, as the recall of Tesla vehicles due to the "Boombox" feature affecting the Pedestrian Warning System sound highlighted a safety concern related to moving vehicles and pedestrian awareness [Article 124320, Article 124043]. (c) The software failure incident did not directly relate to the extraction of materials from Earth. (d) The software failure incident did not directly relate to the sales industry. (e) The software failure incident did not directly relate to the construction industry. (f) The software failure incident did not directly relate to the manufacturing industry. (g) The software failure incident did not directly relate to the utilities industry. (h) The software failure incident did not directly relate to the finance industry. (i) The software failure incident did not directly relate to the knowledge industry. (j) The software failure incident did not directly relate to the health industry. (k) The software failure incident did not directly relate to the entertainment industry. (l) The software failure incident did not directly relate to the government industry. (m) The failed system was not related to an industry not described in the options provided.

Sources

Back to List